What should you say when a seller’s ChatGPT home value is higher than your CMA?
Don’t argue with the chatbot, says Jason Pantana. Ask the seller what comparable sales and home details their AI used, then open ChatGPT together and give it your comps, adjustments, competing listings, and reasoning. Ask it to evaluate the range and explain its evidence in plain language, so the seller sees what their own AI says when it has better inputs.
Your seller says, “ChatGPT says my home is worth $850,000.” Your CMA (comparative market analysis, your pricing report built from comparable sales) says more like $790,000. Don’t defend your number. Ask questions first, then hand the AI your evidence.
That’s the advice from Jason Pantana, co-founder of Ai Marketing Academy (AiM). Push back on the price and the appointment turns into a contest between you and a chatbot. As he puts it, “You don’t need to win an argument against a chatbot.” You need the seller to see the same evidence you’ve been working from.
What questions should you ask the seller first?
Ask what the AI based its number on. Pantana’s opening questions are:
- What comparable sales did it use?
- What does it know about the condition of your home?
- What does it know about the improvements you’ve made?
- What does it know about the active listings you’re competing against?
You can also ask which comparable sales it missed. These questions aren’t a trap. They show the seller, without any pushback from you, that a valuation is only as good as what went into it.
How do you use ChatGPT with the seller at the listing appointment?
Open ChatGPT together and give it what the seller’s version didn’t have. Here’s the process:
- Open ChatGPT with the seller. Do it side by side, not behind your laptop.
- Give it your comps. Use the comparable sales you analyzed, including any the seller’s AI didn’t use.
- Add the property details. Include condition and improvements.
- Add your adjustments. These are the value changes you made for differences between the home and each comp.
- Add the competing inventory. Include the active listings the home will be up against.
- Add your reasoning. Explain why you chose those comps and made those adjustments.
- Ask it to evaluate the range and explain its evidence in plain language.
Then let it do some of the talking. The goal is for the seller to hear the explanation from the same tool they trusted in the first place.
Why does this work better than defending your number?
It changes the question the seller is answering. “The seller isn’t being asked to choose between your opinion and their AI’s opinion.” They’re seeing what their AI says when it has the market evidence you’ve used from the start.
Jason’s summary: “It’s the same technology, but better inputs. The difference is the experience and judgment that went into choosing those inputs.” Your value isn’t owning a smarter tool. It’s knowing which comps belong, which adjustments are fair, and which listings the home will compete with.
The same idea shows up on the buyer side, where ChatGPT can make home buyers cancel deals when it answers without the full picture. In both cases, your job is to supply the context.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should you tell a seller that ChatGPT is wrong about their home value?
No. Pantana’s advice is “Don’t fight their AI.” Ask what it used, then give it better information and let it help explain the conclusion.
What information should you give ChatGPT during a pricing conversation?
Give it the comps you analyzed, the property details, your adjustments, the competing inventory, and your reasoning. Then ask it to evaluate the range and explain its evidence in plain language.
Why is an agent’s CMA different from the seller’s ChatGPT estimate?
It comes down to inputs. When ChatGPT has the agent’s market evidence, it’s the same technology with better inputs, and the difference is the experience and judgment used to choose them.
What questions should you ask a seller about their AI home valuation?
Ask what comparable sales it used and which ones it missed. Ask what it knows about the home’s condition, the improvements, and the active listings the home is competing against.
Bring Better Inputs to Your Next Listing Appointment
Sellers will keep showing up with an AI’s number, and the agents who know how to work with that AI will keep the conversation, and the listing. Ai Marketing Academy gives you step-by-step trainings, ready-to-run AI systems, prompts, and live sessions built for real estate agents. See what’s inside Ai Marketing Academy.
